Here’s a number that should feel like good news: about two-thirds of teachers, school administrators and district leaders now say they’ve had at least one professional development session on AI. That’s up 11 percentage points from last year’s 56%, according to a new EdWeek Research Center survey of 852 educators published this week.
Now read the rest of the story.
The teachers EdWeek talked to described AI professional development for teachers that is optional, poorly attended, light on practice and almost silent on the questions keeping them up at night: cheating, critical thinking, jobs, the environment. One Dallas teacher who leads AI training in his district put it plainly: “These trainings are all-in on the new stuff.”
I’ve been in enough school libraries at 3:30 on a Wednesday to know that feeling. More sessions is not the same as better learning. And the gap between the two is exactly where school leaders have work to do.
Key takeaways
- AI PD has spread fast: about two-thirds of educators report at least one session, up from 56% a year ago (EdWeek Research Center).
- Teachers say the trainings are often optional, so the skeptics skip them, and they focus on demos instead of hands-on practice and peer discussion.
- The hard questions — academic integrity, critical thinking, jobs, environmental impact — are rarely addressed, even though that’s what teachers want to talk about.
- Research on effective PD points to the fix: active, collaborative, coached learning sustained over time, not one more feature tour.
What’s missing from AI professional development for teachers
The EdWeek piece is worth reading in full, but four gaps jump out.
It’s optional, so the wrong people show up. Turnout is low because the sessions aren’t mandatory, and the people who attend are the ones already curious. The skeptics — the teachers you most need in the room — aren’t there.
It’s a demo, not practice. A West Virginia science teacher said it best: “Teachers don’t want another demonstration of what AI can do.” A Wisconsin instructional coach noted that prompts don’t always behave the way you expect and asked for practice resources — something as simple as a fake spreadsheet to experiment on safely.
It’s one-and-done. Teachers want time with peers to work through what they’re seeing, and they don’t want a single session to be the end of the conversation.
It skips the hard questions. Cheating detection and prevention, critical thinking, the job market and environmental impact are, in one trainer’s words, “not really touched on.”
Read that list again. None of it is about which tool to buy. All of it is about how adults learn.
Why the skeptics matter most
I’ll admit something: when I run a workshop, the energy from early adopters is wonderful. But the room I worry about is the one down the hall — the teachers who didn’t sign up.
Those teachers aren’t wrong to be skeptical. Many of them are asking the exact questions EdWeek’s respondents said PD ignores. Is this going to make my students stop thinking? How do I know whose work this is? What happens to the jobs my students are preparing for? If your AI training answers those questions with a slide of shiny features, you’ve just confirmed their suspicion that nobody is taking their concerns seriously.
Here’s the irony. Skeptics often make the best AI teachers once they engage, because they bring the critical eye that students need. I’ve written before about why fear needs to be addressed, not dismissed, in AI professional development. One workshop participant summed up what happens when the conversation goes deeper:
“Using AI in the right way can elevate the quality of the learning itself, not just as a cheat bot”
That shift doesn’t happen in a demo. It happens when people have time to argue, test and reflect together.
What the research says about building capacity
None of this is new to school leaders. You know what good professional learning looks like. The Learning Policy Institute’s review of 35 methodologically rigorous studies, Effective Teacher Professional Development (Darling-Hammond, Hyler & Gardner, 2017), found that effective PD is content focused, incorporates active learning, supports collaboration, uses models of effective practice, provides coaching and expert support, offers feedback and reflection, and is of sustained duration.
Line that up against the EdWeek findings and the gaps map almost one-to-one. Demos instead of active learning. Optional sessions instead of collaboration across a whole staff. Single sessions instead of sustained duration. Feature tours instead of content tied to what teachers actually teach and worry about.
It isn’t just K-12. In a companion EdWeek survey of 268 teacher educators, only 14% said they’d received ongoing professional development on AI, roughly half had one or a few sessions with no follow-up, and 68% said they want ongoing or multiple sessions. The people who prepare our future teachers are asking for the same thing our current teachers are.
I’ve seen this movie before. Since 2009 I’ve been partnering with schools on technology rollouts, starting with 1:1 laptop programs. The lesson from that wave was simple: the devices didn’t change learning. Sustained support for teachers did. Back in 2017 I wrote on The Thinking Stick that long-term, embedded PD is the best kind of professional development. AI hasn’t changed that. It’s made it more urgent, because the tools keep moving under our feet.
What school leaders can do this month
- Find out who’s not in the room. Pull attendance from your AI sessions this year. Then have a few honest conversations with teachers who didn’t come. Ask what would make it worth their time.
- Put the hard questions on the agenda. Make your next AI session about academic integrity or critical thinking, not a tool. Invite the skeptics to help design it. The Shifting Schools podcast episode Beyond Cheating, a conversation with Justin Reich and Jesse Dukes of MIT’s The Homework Machine, is a strong pre-read for a staff discussion.
- Swap one demo for one practice block. Give teachers safe, low-stakes material to practice on — sample student work with names removed, a mock data set, a unit plan they actually teach — and time to compare results with a colleague.
- Use the time you already have. PLCs, department meetings and coaching cycles are already on the calendar. Dedicate 20 minutes of one each month to AI practice and reflection rather than adding another optional after-school session.
- Give your coaches a role. Instructional coaches can turn a one-time workshop into a cycle of try, reflect, refine. If you’re not sure where to start, I wrote about coaching teachers who are at different places with AI.
- Decide what “good” looks like. Agree as a leadership team on two or three classroom practices you want to see by spring, and use our AI for teachers guide to anchor the conversation.
Why this is partnership work
You can do every item on that list without hiring anyone. Many schools should start there. But here’s what I see across schools in the US and internationally: the first round of AI PD is easy to schedule. Keeping it going — through staff turnover, new platform features, retirements of tools people just learned, and a board asking for results — is where it stalls. Internal teams are stretched thin, and a vendor’s free training is built to teach its product, not your priorities.
A long-term partnership looks different. Across a school year, that might mean working with the leadership team on vision and guidance in the fall, coaching instructional coaches so they can carry the work, hands-on sessions with teachers that tackle integrity and critical thinking head-on, student sessions on AI literacy, and a parent night and board conversation so the whole community understands the why. Face-to-face, virtual or both, depending on what your school needs. Every contract is different, which is why I call it a partnership.
It works when it grows over time. The Alaska Staff Development Network ran my five-part AI series in Fall 2024 with 50+ educators, brought it back in Spring 2025 for 30+ more, and added advanced sessions on reimagining assessment and learning with bots. You can read about it on our Shifting Schools success stories page. That’s what sustained looks like: each round goes deeper than the last. The goal isn’t to make you dependent on me. It’s to build the capacity inside your school so the learning keeps going when I’m not there.
FAQ
What should AI professional development for teachers include?
Hands-on practice with realistic materials, time for peer discussion, and direct work on the hard questions — academic integrity, critical thinking and student wellbeing — sustained over months with coaching and follow-up, not a single feature demo.
Should AI training be mandatory for teachers?
Optional sessions tend to attract teachers who are already enthusiastic. Building AI learning into existing PLC, department and coaching time reaches the whole staff, including skeptics, without simply adding another required session.
How long does it take to build AI capacity in a school?
Think in school years, not workshops. The research on effective PD emphasizes sustained duration, and because AI platforms change constantly, schools need ongoing cycles of learning rather than a one-time rollout.
The bottom line
More AI PD is happening. That’s progress. But teachers are telling us it’s the wrong kind: optional, demo-driven and quiet on the questions that matter most. The fix isn’t more sessions. It’s better learning, built over time, with everyone in the room.
So here’s my question for you: who on your staff has skipped every AI session this year — and what would it take to make the next one worth their time?
If you want to think that through together, book a 30-minute call with me. Pricing and packaging are tailored to each school, so reach out and we’ll talk through what a partnership could look like for yours. You can also email me at jeff@jeffutecht.com. And if you want something to listen to on the drive home, try the episode How Generative AI Can Deepen Critical Thinking in K12, Not Replace It.
Sources
- Lauraine Langreo, Education Week, “Teachers Pinpoint What’s Missing in Professional Development About AI,” November 16, 2026.
- Alyson Klein, Education Week, “AI Raises Big Questions for the Future of Teacher Education,” November 16, 2026.
- Linda Darling-Hammond, Maria E. Hyler & Madelyn Gardner, Learning Policy Institute, “Effective Teacher Professional Development,” June 5, 2017.